Where to Sell Old Adult Magazines: eBay's Rules, Dealers, and What Works
Selling old adult magazines got harder in 2024. eBay, where nearly all of them used to sell, closed its Adult Only category that July and stopped accepting new listings for sexually explicit magazines. Playboy, Penthouse, Playgirl and Mayfair are still allowed, with conditions; Hustler and most of the explicit titles aren't. Facebook Marketplace and Mercari don't allow adult magazines at all. That leaves a shorter list of places than people expect, and most of them want lots, not single issues. Here's where you can still sell, what each place wants, and how to price a box.
What eBay allows now
Since 15 July 2024, eBay no longer accepts listings for adult magazines, books or comics with sexually explicit content. Its policy names four magazines that can still be listed in the ordinary Magazines category: Playboy, Penthouse, Playgirl and Mayfair, on the condition that the listing itself shows no nudity. In practice that means:
- List in Books & Magazines > Magazines, not an adult category (that category no longer exists).
- Photograph the cover, spine and any flaws. Don't photograph inside pages that show nudity. Keep the listing images to the cover.
- For vintage issues, you're responsible for confirming everyone pictured was an adult when the photos were taken, which is why most sellers stick to the major titles. The best-known problem is Traci Lords, who appeared in several 1984–86 magazines, including the September 1984 Penthouse, while underage: those issues can't legally be sold anywhere in the US.
- Hustler and the explicit second-tier titles (Cheri, Club, Swank, High Society, the digest titles) are generally not listable. Sellers who try usually get the listing removed.
eBay is still the best place for anything valuable among the permitted titles, because that's where the buyers and the sold-price history are. See Playboy values and Penthouse and Hustler values for what the individual issues sell for.
Where the rest can go
Specialist dealers. A handful of dealers buy vintage men's magazines by the collection, nationwide, and will quote on a list or photos. They generally want 25 or more issues, prefer pre-1990 material, and pay well below retail because they have to resell and ship. For a box of common 1990s and 2000s issues, a dealer offer may be the only realistic buyer. Search for "vintage magazine buyers" and check they handle adult titles before you send a list.
Bookseller marketplaces. Sites like Biblio and AbeBooks host vintage magazine dealers, and some of them stock adult titles. These are mainly for selling through a dealer rather than listing yourself.
Collector forums and communities. Magazine-collecting groups and subreddits often have buy/sell threads, and buyers there know what they're looking at. Payment protection is weaker than on eBay, so sell to established members and use a payment method with buyer and seller protection.
Comic and magazine shows, flea markets and antique malls. Some dealers at these events handle vintage men's magazines. Lots sell for cash, no fees, no shipping, and no platform rules.
Local sale. Craigslist still allows adult items in some regions; Facebook Marketplace doesn't. Expect low prices, because the buyers are usually dealers.
Auction houses. Only for serious early material: a run of 1950s Playboys, a first issue, a large pre-1975 collection. Regional auction houses do run vintage adult magazine lots. Fees are 20 to 40 percent, so this is for collections worth real money.
How to price a lot
- Sort first. Pull out anything valuable (early issues, first issues, famous covers, sealed copies) and sell those individually where allowed. Our guide to are old adult magazines worth anything covers what's worth pulling out.
- Group the rest by title and decade. "Penthouse 1990s, 12 issues" sells better than a mixed pile.
- Price the lot at roughly a third to a half of what the issues would fetch individually. Buyers of lots are paying for the convenience and expect a discount; dealers will offer less again.
- Describe condition honestly: mailing labels, missing pages, damp, smell. Returns and disputes on magazines are almost always about condition.
- Ship flat and rigid. Magazines in a padded envelope arrive creased. Use a box or a rigid mailer, and in the US, Media Mail is the cheap option for heavy bundles.
The Valued app will identify an issue from a photo of the cover and give you a starting estimate, which makes the sort in step 1 quick when there's a whole box. For the method behind any valuation, see finding out what an antique is worth.
Common questions
Can you sell adult magazines on eBay?
Only some. Since July 2024, eBay allows Playboy, Penthouse, Playgirl and Mayfair in the Magazines category, provided the listing shows no nudity. Hustler and most explicit titles can no longer be listed.
Can you sell Playboy magazines on Facebook Marketplace?
No. Facebook Marketplace prohibits adult products, and Playboy listings are routinely removed. Mercari has the same rule.
Who buys old adult magazines?
Specialist vintage magazine dealers, collectors in magazine-collecting communities, and dealers at comic and magazine shows. Most want lots of 25 or more issues and pay well below retail.
Are old adult magazines worth selling at all?
The early issues and first issues, yes. Ordinary 1980s–2000s issues are worth $1 to $15 each and only make sense to sell as lots, or to a dealer who takes the whole box.