Are Old Adult Magazines Worth Anything? Variations, Cheri, Club, Swank and the Rest: Most Are $1–15
Most adult magazines that aren't Playboy or Penthouse sell for $1 to $15 an issue, and the ones from the 1990s and 2000s sit at the bottom of that range. Penthouse Variations, Forum and Letters, Cheri, Club, Swank, Gallery, High Society, Oui and the dozens of small digest titles were printed in large numbers, kept by a lot of people, and have a small collector market. A box of them is usually worth more as one or two lots than as fifty individual listings. Here's what each group is worth, the few exceptions worth pulling out, and how to sort a box in an evening.
The honest ranges
| Title group | Typical price per issue (clean, complete) |
|---|---|
| Penthouse Variations, Forum, Letters | $1–$5, usually sold in lots |
| Cheri, Club, Swank, Gallery, High Society, Genesis, Fox | $3–$12; 1970s issues at the top |
| Oui (1972–1980s) | $5–$15; early-1970s issues and famous covers higher |
| Hustler | $5–$20; see our Penthouse and Hustler page |
| Small-press and digest titles (40+, Family Tales, Tight Squeeze and similar) | $1–$10; premiere issues at the top |
| Anything from 2000 onward, any title | $1–$8 |
Those are prices for clean copies with all pages, no mailing label and no damp. Worn copies sell for less, or don't sell.
A 26-issue lot of Penthouse Variations spanning 1978 to 2005 is a typical eBay listing, and a lot of 20 mixed High Society, Cheri and Club issues from 2004–05 is another. Lots like these sell in the tens of dollars, not the hundreds.
Why they're worth so little
Playboy has a collector market because it has famous covers, famous interviews and a first issue people chase. The second-tier titles have none of that. They were bought, read and stored by the millions; the supply is enormous; and the buyers are mostly people filling gaps in a run of one title. So a single ordinary issue competes with hundreds of identical copies, and the price settles near the cost of shipping it.
That's also why lots do better than singles. A buyer who wants ten issues of Cheri from 1990 would rather pay $40 once than $5 ten times with ten shipping charges.
The exceptions worth pulling out
- First and early issues of any title. Oui's 1972 debut, High Society's 1976 debut, Club's early-1970s issues and the premiere issue of almost any small title sell for several times the ordinary price, because collectors of that title want them.
- 1970s issues generally. Fewer survive, and the covers and layouts have a retro appeal. Oui in particular was a glossier, Playboy-owned title and is the most collected of this group.
- Issues with a famous cover model or a notable interview. Worth a quick search of the exact month and year.
- Sealed, unread copies. Some 1990s and 2000s issues were sold bagged. Still-sealed copies sell for noticeably more than opened ones.
- Special editions and annuals. Anniversary issues, "best of" collections and supplements can be worth more than regular numbers.
Everything else is bulk, and that's fine. Bulk still sells.
One thing that can't be sold. Traci Lords appeared in a number of adult magazines in 1984–86, including the September 1984 Penthouse, while she was underage. Any issue featuring her from that period can't legally be sold or distributed in the US, and no reputable buyer will take it. If one turns up in a box, don't list it.
How to sort a box
- Pull out anything with Playboy or Penthouse on the cover and check those separately: Playboy values and Penthouse and Hustler values are different markets.
- Pull out anything from before 1980, any first issue, and anything sealed. Those are the ones to look up individually.
- Group the rest by title and decade. Those become your lots.
- Check condition as you go: mailing labels, missing pages, water marks, smell. Damaged copies go in a "free with purchase" pile or the recycling.
- Search sold listings on eBay for the few you pulled out: exact title, month and year, filtered to Sold items.
The Valued app will identify an issue from a photo of the cover and give you a starting estimate, which is the fast way through step 2 when the box has eighty magazines in it. For the general method, see our guide to finding out what an antique is worth.
Once you know what you've got, the harder part is where to sell it, because the big marketplaces have rules about adult magazines. Our page on where to sell old adult magazines covers what each platform allows.
Common questions
Are Penthouse Variations magazines worth anything?
Very little individually: $1 to $5 an issue, and they usually sell as lots of ten or more. Issues from the late 1970s and early 1980s are at the top of that range.
Are 1990s adult magazines worth money?
Usually $1 to $10 an issue for the second-tier titles, and $2 to $8 for 1990s Penthouse. Sealed copies and first issues of a title are the exceptions.
Which old adult magazines are worth the most?
Early Playboy by a wide margin, then first issues of Penthouse, Oui, High Society, Club and Hustler, then 1970s issues generally. Ordinary 1980s–2000s issues of any title are worth a few dollars.
Is it better to sell adult magazines individually or as a lot?
As lots, grouped by title and decade, unless an issue is a first issue, pre-1980, sealed, or has a famous cover. Individual listings for ordinary issues rarely cover the time and fees.