How to Check What a Card Is Worth: Pokémon, Sports and Magic Cards
To find out what a trading card is worth, you need three things: the exact card (set, number and version), its condition, and recent sold prices for that same card in that same condition. Get any one wrong and the number is meaningless, because two cards that look identical can be worth $2 and $2,000. This works the same for Pokémon, baseball, basketball, football and Magic: The Gathering cards.
1. Identify the exact card
The name alone isn't enough. Check:
- Set and card number. Usually printed at the bottom of the card, like 4/102 on a Pokémon card.
- Year and brand for sports cards (for example, 1986 Fleer), and whether it's a true rookie card.
- The version. Holo, reverse holo, first edition, shadowless, a numbered parallel, a refractor or an insert can multiply the value.
- Language. Japanese and English versions of the same card sell for different prices.
2. Judge the condition honestly
Condition drives the price more than anything except the card itself. Look at it under a bright light:
- Corners: sharp or rounded and white?
- Edges: any whitening or chips?
- Surface: scratches, print lines, dents or creases?
- Centering: are the borders even on all sides?
A card that looks fine at arm's length often has whitening on the back edges. Be strict: buyers will be.
3. Check sold prices, not asking prices
- eBay sold listings. Search the exact card and filter by "Sold items". This is the best single source, because it shows what people actually paid.
- Price guides like PriceCharting and TCGplayer track recent sales and are quick for popular cards. Treat them as a starting point and check sold listings for anything valuable.
- Match raw to raw and graded to graded. A PSA 10 can sell for many times a PSA 8, and an ungraded card sells for less than a graded one in similar condition.
Should you get it graded?
Grading (by PSA, Beckett or CGC) costs money and takes time, so it's only worth it when a high grade would add much more than the fee. A good rule: grade cards that are worth at least $100 raw and look close to perfect. Most cards aren't worth grading.
The quick way
If you have a stack of cards to sort, the Valued app identifies a card from a photo and gives a starting estimate, so you can find the few worth looking up properly. For specifics, see which Pokémon cards are worth money and which old baseball cards are worth anything.
Common questions
How do I find out how much my cards are worth?
Identify the exact card and version, check its condition, then look up recent sold prices for that card in the same condition on eBay or a price guide.
Is there an app that scans cards for prices?
Yes. Valued identifies a card from a photo and gives an estimate based on recent sales. Check sold listings before selling anything valuable.
Are PriceCharting prices accurate?
They're a useful average of recent sales for popular cards. For valuable or unusual cards, check recent eBay sold listings for your exact card and condition.
Which cards are worth grading?
Cards worth roughly $100 or more ungraded that look nearly perfect. For most cards, grading costs more than it adds.